
Introduction
The Commercial Code provides a comprehensive framework governing the treatment of contractual relationships, the composition and administration of the insolvency estate, and the invalidation of transactions undertaken during the insolvency proceedings. The Bankruptcy Book establishes rules addressing the continuation or termination of ongoing contracts, new financing and transactions undertaken during the continuation of the debtor’s business, while also regulating the identification, administration and realization of assets and the treatment and priority of creditors’ claims. It further establishes an avoidance regime designed to protect the insolvency estate and the collective interests of creditors by permitting certain transactions undertaken during the suspect period to be invalidated. This analysis examines Book Three provisions governing the treatment of contracts, the insolvency estate and avoidance proceedings, with particular emphasis on their implications for participants of insolvency proceedings.
Treatment of Contracts
Treatment of Ongoing Contracts
An ongoing contract is broadly defined under the Commercial Code to include contracts under which at least one party has an unperformed contractual obligation at the time proceedings are opened, including essential-services contracts and leases of immovable business premises. The Commercial Code establishes the continuity of ongoing contracts following the commencement of preventive restructuring, reorganization or bankruptcy proceedings. The opening of proceedings does not, by itself, entitle a contractual counterparty to terminate, accelerate, suspend or otherwise modify an ongoing contract.
The Commercial Code further restricts the operation of ipso facto clauses. Contractual provisions allowing a creditor to withhold performance, terminate, accelerate or otherwise modify an ongoing contract solely on the basis of the debtor’s request for or commencement of insolvency proceedings, or a stay granted in preventive restructuring, are rendered ineffective. This is intended to preserve the debtor’s ability to maintain its operations during the insolvency process. At the same time, the Commercial Code gives the supervisor in reorganization and the trustee in bankruptcy the authority to terminate ongoing contracts where the debtor or the estate lacks sufficient funds to perform the contract, continuation is not in the interest of the debtor or the estate, or early termination would not unfairly prejudice creditors. A creditor may request a decision on whether to continue or terminate the contract, subject to the expedited procedure prescribed by the Commercial Code.
A creditor affected by a decision to continue or terminate an ongoing contract may oppose the decision within seven consecutive days. The short period underscores the need for contractual counterparties to monitor decisions made by the supervisor or trustee and act promptly where the continuation or termination of a contract affects their interests. Special protection is provided for leases of immovable business premises. The Commercial Code restricts provisions requiring the immediate payment of rent for the entire remaining term of the lease during the initial four months of the observation period in reorganization, or during the continuation period applicable in bankruptcy. This provision seeks to prevent the insolvency process from creating an immediate and disproportionate rent liability for the estate.
The general regime does not apply to certain categories of contracts, including employment contracts, banking and insurance contracts, administrative contracts, and contracts concluded within financial markets, which are subject to their respective specialized legal regimes.
New Financing
The Commercial Code expressly facilitates new financing during insolvency proceedings and establishes different regimes depending on whether the debtor is undergoing preventive restructuring, reorganization or bankruptcy. The treatment of such financing is particularly significant because the Commercial Code gives new financiers a statutory priority over ordinary unsecured creditors.
In preventive restructuring, new financing must be included in the restructuring plan and approved by the Court as part of the plan. The new financing has priority over unsecured creditors if bankruptcy is subsequently opened. The judgment approving the restructuring plan must also make the amount of the new financing publicly available. In reorganization, new financing may be provided by existing or new creditors to implement the reorganization plan. The financing must be included in the reorganization plan and confirmed by the Court. Where bankruptcy subsequently occurs, such financing ranks ahead of unsecured creditors but below new financing granted in preventive restructuring. In bankruptcy, new financing is permitted only in exceptional cases and upon approval of the creditors’ committee, where it is required to finance the continuation of the debtor’s business. Such financing has priority over unsecured creditors but ranks below new financing provided in preventive restructuring and reorganization.
Article 786 establishes the overall ranking of new financing in bankruptcy. Following realization of encumbered assets, the proceeds are distributed according to a statutory order in which costs and expenses of the proceedings rank first; the new financing granted in preventive restructuring ranks next; the new financing granted in reorganization follows and the new financing authorized in bankruptcy ranks thereafter. Post-bankruptcy creditors, including creditors arising from new and ongoing contracts, rank after these categories.
Trade-Related Contracts and Going-Concern Sales
Where the debtor’s business is authorized to continue operating after the commencement of bankruptcy proceedings, creditors arising from new trade transactions entered into during the bankruptcy proceedings are treated as post-bankruptcy creditors. The Commercial Code provides that such creditors are entitled to payment in accordance with the contractual terms governing the relevant transaction. Where their claims remain unpaid, they have priority over unsecured creditors, subject to the higher priority accorded to new financing.
The Commercial Code expressly places post-bankruptcy creditors after new financing providers in preventive restructuring, reorganization and bankruptcy, but ahead of employee claims, tax claims, other preferred creditors and ordinary unsecured creditors. Accordingly, suppliers and other trade creditors who extend goods or services to a debtor during an authorized continuation of its business benefit from a statutory priority that distinguishes their post-bankruptcy claims from ordinary pre-bankruptcy trade debts.
The Insolvency Estate
Assets Constituting the Estate
The Commercial Code establishes the insolvency estate as the pool of assets available for the satisfaction of creditors, while distinguishing between the debtor’s position during reorganization and the trustee’s control following the opening of bankruptcy. During the observation period, the debtor generally remains in possession of its assets, subject to the supervision applicable to the relevant proceeding and the stay of individual enforcement. Upon the opening of bankruptcy, the trustee assumes control of the estate and is responsible for identifying, securing, taking inventory of and administering the debtor’s assets.
An exception to the assets forming part of the insolvency estate applies to property belonging to third parties but held by the debtor at the commencement of bankruptcy. The Commercial Code permits the owners or other persons entitled to such property to seek its recovery from the estate. This includes, among others, property delivered to the debtor on deposit or for sale, goods subject to a retention-of-title arrangement, and certain goods in transit. Accordingly, the mere possession of property by the debtor at the commencement of bankruptcy does not, by itself, cause such property to form part of the insolvency estate.
Treatment of Creditors’ Claims
The insolvency framework distinguishes between pre-insolvency and post-insolvency claims, primarily by reference to when the particular claim arises. A pre-insolvency claim is a claim that arose before the opening of reorganization or bankruptcy proceedings, regardless of whether it had become due and payable at that time. By contrast, a claim arising after the opening of proceedings is generally treated as a post-insolvency claim. This distinction is particularly important because post-insolvency claims arising in the course of administering or continuing the business may receive different treatment and priority from ordinary pre-insolvency claims.
The distinction is particularly relevant to ongoing contracts. Where an ongoing contract continues after the commencement of proceedings, claims arising from performance after commencement are treated as post-insolvency claims, even though the underlying contract was entered into before the insolvency proceedings. Conversely, penalties and other indemnities arising from the termination of an ongoing contract by the supervisor or trustee are treated as pre-insolvency claims. Thus, the classification depends on the circumstances and timing in which the particular claim arises, rather than simply on the date on which the underlying contract was concluded.
Pre-insolvency creditors are required to establish and submit their claims through the insolvency process, following which the claims are examined and admitted for purposes of participation and distribution. The framework also distinguishes between secured, preferred, unsecured and subordinated claims, with the applicable classification affecting the creditor’s position in the distribution of the estate. Post-insolvency claims arising in the administration or continuation of the estate may receive priority over pre-insolvency claims, reflecting their role in preserving or administering the estate.
Use and Disposal of Assets
The use and disposal of assets forming part of the insolvency estate depend on the nature and stage of the insolvency proceeding. During reorganization, the debtor generally remains in possession of its assets and may continue using them in the ordinary course of business, subject to the supervision and restrictions applicable to the proceeding. Once bankruptcy is opened, control of the estate shifts to the trustee, who is responsible for preserving, administering and ultimately realizing the assets for the benefit of creditors. Where continuation of the business is authorized, the trustee may continue operating the business for the prescribed period and may take measures necessary to preserve or enhance the value of the estate, including obtaining new financing or compromising claims of the estate where permitted.
The disposal of estate assets is subject to different rules depending on whether the objective is to preserve the business as a going concern or to realize individual assets. A sale of the business as a going concern is treated differently from the sale of individual assets, reflecting the potential value of preserving the debtor’s business operations. In bankruptcy, where assets are realized individually, the proceeds are subject to the applicable rules governing secured creditors and the statutory order of distribution. Secured creditors retain their rights over encumbered assets, while any residual value becomes available for distribution through the estate.
The realization process is therefore closely linked to the priority and distribution framework. Costs and expenses of the proceedings, secured claims and other claims ranking ahead of ordinary unsecured creditors must be taken into account before distributions are made. The Commercial Code also permits interim distributions in appropriate circumstances and requires amounts to be retained where necessary to account for unresolved claims or other contingencies before final distribution of the estate.
Avoidance Proceedings
The Commercial Code requires the court to determine the date of cessation of payments when insolvency proceedings are opened. The period between that date and the opening of proceedings constitutes the suspect period, which may not exceed eighteen months. Transactions undertaken during this period are not automatically invalid; rather, they are subject to the specific grounds for invalidation established by the Commercial Code. In bankruptcy, the trustee may pursue the invalidation of transactions undertaken during the suspect period that were not already invalidated during reorganization.
Mandatory and Optional Invalidation
The Commercial Code establishes both mandatory and discretionary grounds for invalidation. Mandatory invalidation applies to specified transactions that are considered inherently prejudicial to the estate or capable of improperly altering the position of creditors. These include gratuitous transfers or waivers of rights, transfers for a manifestly inadequate price, certain payments of debts that are not yet due, certain non-cash payments of due debts, and the creation of security interests over the debtor’s assets for pre-existing debts. Where the prescribed conditions are established, the court is required to invalidate the transaction.
Other transactions may be invalidated where they are detrimental to the estate or give an unjustified preference to a creditor, provided that the creditor knew or ought to have known that the debtor was already in a situation of cessation of payments. The creditor’s knowledge therefore constitutes an important element of optional invalidation, and the supervisor bears the burden of proving that knowledge, subject to the special rule applicable to transactions with related parties. The distinction between the two categories is therefore significant: mandatory invalidation focuses on the nature of the transaction itself, whereas optional invalidation additionally requires consideration of its effect and the counterparty’s knowledge.
Exempted Transactions and Registered Rights
The avoidance regime does not extend to certain transactions that the Commercial Code seeks to protect, particularly transactions necessary for restructuring or ordinary business operations. These include transactions carried out pursuant to a court-confirmed restructuring plan, realization of certain security interests, acquisitions necessary for the ordinary course of business, and good-faith purchases of goods or services for a fair price, subject to the exception for fraud. The Commercial Code also addresses the registration of rights arising from validly created security interests before the judgment opening proceedings. This is particularly relevant to the preservation and priority of security rights and underscores the importance of completing the applicable registration or perfection requirements before insolvency proceedings are opened.
Standing, Procedure, Limitation and Consequences
During reorganization, the supervisor is responsible for pursuing invalidation where this would benefit the estate or prevent an unjustified preference. Where the supervisor declines to act, a controller or creditor may, subject to the prescribed conditions, institute proceedings on behalf of the estate. Following the opening of bankruptcy, the trustee assumes the corresponding powers and may pursue transactions that remain subject to invalidation. Avoidance proceedings are subject to a two-year limitation period, with a specific adjustment where the debtor failed to disclose the relevant transaction to the supervisor. Invalidation operates retroactively, and where restitution in kind is not possible, the market value of the relevant property is returned to the estate. The purpose is therefore to restore value improperly removed from the estate and to ensure that the consequences of a transaction undertaken during the suspect period do not prejudice the collective interests of creditors.
Conclusion
The Commercial Code adopts a framework intended to preserve the value of the debtor’s business while protecting the collective interests of creditors. Its treatment of ongoing contracts seeks to maintain contractual relationships necessary for continued operations, while allowing termination where continuation is no longer justified. The framework for new financing and post-bankruptcy trade transactions further supports business continuity by granting defined priority to claims arising from financing and transactions undertaken during the insolvency process.
At the same time, the provisions governing the insolvency estate establish a clear distinction between assets available for creditor satisfaction and property belonging to third parties, while the classification of claims determines their treatment and priority in distribution. The avoidance regime complements these rules by allowing transactions undertaken during the suspect period to be invalidated where they improperly prejudice the estate, while preserving certain transactions necessary for restructuring and ordinary business operations.
Overall, the framework reflects a balance between business continuity, preservation of estate value and equitable treatment of creditors. For creditors and counterparties, the practical significance lies in identifying the timing and nature of their claims, understanding the priority applicable to them and ensuring that security rights are properly established before insolvency proceedings commence. For debtors and insolvency practitioners, compliance with the statutory rules on the administration of assets, continuation of contracts, new financing and avoidance is essential to preserve the estate and minimize the risk of transactions being subsequently challenged.
This article is general information and not legal advice. Contact us about your specific situation.



