
Part 3 of 4
The International Rules of the Carbon Market
Introduction
Carbon markets do not operate in a legal vacuum. For a carbon credit generated in Ethiopia to be sold to a government buyer in Japan, Norway, or Singapore, or to a corporation in London or New York, it must comply with a layered architecture of international rules. Rules that were debated, contested, and progressively clarified across thirty years of climate diplomacy. Rules that, until very recently, were incomplete enough to make buyers hesitant and developers cautious.
The COP29 decisions of November 2024, finalising the Article 6 rulebook of the Paris Agreement, represent the most important development in international carbon market law since the Agreement was adopted in December 2015. Understanding what those rules require and what they mean for Ethiopia specifically is essential for anyone working in or around carbon project development, climate finance, or environmental governance.
This series explains why those rules were needed, how they evolved through a decade of negotiation, what they require today, and, critically, what each mechanism means for Ethiopian carbon project developers and investors.
Lessons from the Kyoto Protocol: Why Article 6 of the Paris Agreement Was Needed
To understand Article 6, it is necessary to understand what it was designed to fix. The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) under the Kyoto Protocol was the world’s first large-scale international carbon crediting system. At its peak, it registered over 7,800 projects across developing countries and issued more than 2 billion Certified Emission Reductions (CERs). Yet it ultimately failed to deliver the environmental credibility or the development impact its architects intended. Among the structural weaknesses, the two major weaknesses are:
- Demand concentration and collapse: Almost all CDM demand came from the European Union Emissions Trading System.
- Structural double counting: Under the Kyoto Protocol, developing countries had no binding emissions targets. This meant the same tonne of emission reduction could be counted by the buyer country toward its Kyoto target and retained by the host country in its national greenhouse gas inventory. No corresponding adjustment existed because, with no universal targets, there was no universal double-counting problem to solve. The Paris Agreement changed this entirely as it requires every member state to submit its NDC, making corresponding adjustments legally and environmentally essential.
Article 6 of the Paris Agreement was specifically architected to address these failures: creating a universal framework applying to all countries, requiring formal host country authorization, mandating corresponding adjustments to eliminate structural double-counting, and incorporating design features that lower barriers for Least Developed Countries (LDC) participation.
The Paris Agreement’s Architecture for Carbon Markets
Article 6 of the Paris Agreement establishes three parallel but complementary pathways for countries to cooperate on climate action:
- Bilateral Cooperative Approaches (Article 6.2)
- The Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM) (Article 6.4)
- Non-Market Approach (Article 6.8)
Bilateral Cooperative Approaches
Article 6.2 provides the legal basis for Internationally Transferred Mitigation Outcomes (ITMOs), the Paris Agreement’s term for internationally transferred carbon credits that carry full host country authorization and corresponding adjustment. It is the mechanism through which Ethiopia’s most commercially significant carbon transactions will be structured.
Mandatory Requirements to Give Effect to Article 6.2
Every Article 6.2 transaction requires the following three treaty obligations from the host country:
- Authorization: The host country must formally authorise each ITMO before or at the time of first transfer, specifying: (i) the quantity of ITMOs authorised; (ii) the purpose for which they may be used (NDC achievement, Other International Mitigation Purposes such as CORSIA, or voluntary cancellation); and (iii) the applicable time period.
- Corresponding Adjustments: The host country must add the quantity of transferred ITMOs to its reported emissions, effectively reducing the credit the country can claim toward its own NDC by the same amount. The COP29 decisions established that corresponding adjustments must be applied in the calendar year in which the first transfer occurs, resolving a long-standing ambiguity that had complicated bilateral deal structuring. Corresponding adjustments are reported in countries’ Biennial Transparency Reports under the Paris Agreement’s Enhanced Transparency Framework.
- Transparency Reporting: Countries must submit an Initial Report before the first ITMO transfer, Annual Information on all transfers and corresponding adjustments on an ongoing basis, and full Biennial Transparency Reports covering all Article 6 activities. These reports are submitted to the UNFCCC Secretariat and are publicly accessible, creating internationally verifiable accountability for every ITMO transaction.
What COP29 Added to Article 6
One of the most practically important COP29 outcomes for project developers was the clarification of authorization sequencing. Prior to COP29, it was unclear whether a host country authorization could be conditional, amended after issuance, or revoked once issued. The COP29 decisions established:
- Pre-transfer flexibility: Host countries may issue, amend, or revoke authorizations at any point before the first transfer. This allows governments to adjust authorizations based on updated NDC assessments or policy changes.
- Post-transfer finality: Once an ITMO has been first transferred, the authorization cannot be revoked. This gives buyers legal certainty that purchased ITMOs will not be retroactively invalidated.
- Authorization by vintage: Countries may authorize ITMOs from specific activity time periods, enabling staged authorization strategies. For example, authorizing credits from 2025-2027 activities for international transfer while reserving credits from later time periods for domestic NDC accounting.
Ethiopia’s Position Under Article 6.2
Ethiopia is already more prepared for Article 6.2 transactions than most African peers, for a concrete reason: the Standardized Crediting Framework (SCF), established with World Bank support in 2024, provides a pre-agreed governance structure, and authorization procedures for energy sector activities. This means Ethiopia can execute bilateral transactions as soon as bilateral agreements are reached, without building infrastructure from scratch.
The National Carbon Market Strategy identifies priority bilateral partners: Norway, Switzerland, Singapore, South Korea, and Japan. All countries with active demand for high-integrity LDC carbon credits and established legal frameworks for Article 6.2 purchases. Ethiopia’s status as a COP 2027 host adds diplomatic momentum to these negotiations: buyer governments that seek to demonstrate climate finance commitments to LDCs have strong political incentives to conclude bilateral Article 6.2 agreements with Ethiopia before the conference.
Moreover, the Strategy commits to authorizing ITMOs only from conditional NDC targets, mitigation outcomes that Ethiopia cannot achieve with domestic resources alone, and only where international transfers do not compromise achievement of unconditional NDC targets. This constraint is Ethiopia’s sovereign safeguard against overselling. It ensures that carbon market engagement serves NDC achievement rather than undermining it.
The Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism (PACM)
Article 6.4 establishes the PACM, a centralised, UNFCCC-supervised crediting platform that succeeds the CDM while incorporating the governance improvements that three decades of carbon market experience demanded.
Unlike the CDM’s Executive Board, which was frequently criticised for lack of transparency and inconsistency, the PACM is administered by a Supervisory Body with a clear mandate, public deliberations, and an explicit appeals mechanism. The Supervisory Body is responsible for: approving methodologies for measuring and verifying emission reductions; accrediting validation and verification bodies; managing the Article 6.4 registry; overseeing credit issuance; and adjudicating complaints. Its decisions are published and subject to review, a transparency standard that the CDM never fully achieved.
The PACM’s most important innovation compared to the CDM is its two-unit architecture. Host countries make a strategic choice between two categories of credits for each activity or batch of credits:
- Emission Reductions: can be authorised as ITMOs for international transfer, subject to corresponding adjustments. These generate foreign exchange revenue as buyers pay for the right to count the reduction toward their own NDC or other purposes. The seller (for example, Ethiopia) gives up the NDC credit for the transferred tonne.
- Mitigation Contribution Units (MCUs) are not authorised for international transfer. Retained by the host country and counted directly toward its own NDC, with no corresponding adjustment required. MCUs can also be voluntarily cancelled by domestic or international entities for “contribution claims”. For countries like Ethiopia, MCUs are a strategic ring-fence as they allow the country to participate in the PACM, generate revenue from some credits, and simultaneously protect its NDC achievement by designating other credits as non-transferable. Ethiopia’s National Carbon Market Strategy explicitly contemplates the strategic use of MCUs to safeguard against overselling, retaining a proportion of PACM-generated credits as MCUs to ensure conditional NDC targets remain achievable, regardless of how many Emission Reductions are sold internationally.
Ethiopia's transition from CDM to PACM
Ethiopia has seven CDM activities eligible for transition to the PACM, with applications required before December 2025 These include programmes of activities in improved cookstoves, biomass energy, solar lamps, and electrification. These sectors have direct relevance to Ethiopia’s conditional NDC targets. Transitioning these activities preserves the value of existing investments, avoids new transaction costs of PACM registration, and creates an immediate PACM project pipeline that new entrant countries cannot replicate quickly.
The transition also enables scale-up: existing Programmes of Activities can add new Component Project Activities, expanding coverage to new communities, new geographies, and new technology types, under the same program registration. This programmatic expansion is one of the most cost-effective ways to grow Ethiopia’s PACM portfolio in the near term.
The National Carbon Market Strategy identifies the following as priority areas for new PACM activities:
- Electric mobility: Replacing fossil-fuel-based transport with EVs. Ethiopia’s near-100% renewable grid means that each unit of fuel displaced by electricity generates full carbon credits, unlike in countries where electric vehicles are partly charged by fossil-fuel power.
- Off-grid renewable energy for productive use: Solar irrigation, solar water pumping, cold storage for agricultural products, all displacing diesel generators. High mitigation potential with strong development co-benefits.
- Renewable energy exports: Ethiopia exports clean hydropower to neighbouring countries with more emissions-intensive grids. These exports reduce emissions in the importing country and could generate carbon credits under bilateral Article 6.2 arrangements, though corresponding adjustment coordination between power-exporting and power-importing countries requires careful structuring.
- Forest Sector Expansion: Scaling the County’s Forested Landscape Programme; new REDD+ programs in other forest landscapes; reforestation and land restoration under the Green Legacy Initiative.
Non-Market Approaches
Article 6.8 establishes a framework for forms of international cooperation that do not involve carbon credit trading: policy cooperation, capacity building, technology transfer, research and development collaboration, and results-based development finance.
Several of Ethiopia’s most important climate finance needs, registry infrastructure, institutional strengthening of MoPD and the Ethiopian Forestry Development, and technical assistance for PACM methodology development, are better addressed through Article 6.8 arrangements than through carbon credit transactions. The UNFCCC Regional Collaboration Centre for East and Southern Africa, which supported the development of Ethiopia’s National Carbon Market Strategy, operates substantially within the Article 6.8 framework.
CORSIA: The Aviation Sector Carbon Market
The Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation (CORSIA), administered by the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO), is a sector-specific compliance offset program that creates a distinct and growing source of demand for high-quality carbon credits.
CORSIA operates in three phases:
- Pilot phase (2021-2023): Voluntary participation by airlines. Compliance obligations measured against a 2019 emissions baseline, with airlines required to offset growth above that baseline.
- First phase (2024-2026): Voluntary expansion. More countries and airlines are joining. The 2024–2026 compliance period is actively running, with airlines now purchasing CORSIA-eligible credits for current compliance.
- Second phase (2027-2035): Mandatory for all ICAO member states (with narrow exceptions for LDCs, small island states, and low-income countries below certain traffic thresholds). This is when CORSIA demand will reach its full scale.
CORSIA Eligibility
Not all carbon credits are CORSIA-eligible. The ICAO Governing Council has established specific Emissions Unit Criteria (CEUC) that approved programs must meet. Currently approved programs include the Gold Standard, Verra’s Verified Carbon Standard (VCS), the American Carbon Registry, the Climate Action Reserve, and several others. Credits from these programs are CORSIA-eligible if they additionally satisfy:
- Real, additional, and verified: The underlying emission reduction meets additionality and verification standards, the same requirements as any quality carbon credit.
- Not expired: CORSIA has vintage restrictions. Only credits from specific time periods qualify for each compliance cycle.
- Single use: The credit must not have been used for any other purpose (NDC compliance, VCM retirement for corporate claims, domestic compliance). Once retired in a CORSIA context, it cannot be reused.
- No double claiming with NDC: Where a credit originates from a country with an NDC that covers the relevant sector, ICAO increasingly expects a corresponding adjustment aligning CORSIA’s requirements with the Paris Agreement’s corresponding adjustment framework.
Ethiopia’s existing Gold Standard and VCS projects are already registered under CORSIA-approved programs. With Directive No. 1122/2025’s mandatory transparency requirements, particularly the public disclosure of baseline scenarios, additionality claims, and monitoring data, Ethiopian forest carbon credits are well-positioned to satisfy CORSIA’s integrity standards.
The Ethiopian Airlines Opportunity
Ethiopia sits at a unique intersection of CORSIA’s supply and demand sides. Ethiopian Airlines, Africa’s largest international carrier, with routes across multiple CORSIA-participating jurisdictions, faces growing CORSIA compliance obligations. As the airline expands its international network and the mandatory phase approaches, its annual CORSIA obligation will grow substantially.
The National Carbon Market Strategy explicitly identifies CORSIA as a priority channel and contemplates that Ethiopian Airlines should have priority access to a portfolio of CORSIA-eligible credits generated from domestic mitigation activities, including clean cooking, biogas, forestry, and e-mobility. This arrangement would keep climate finance revenues within Ethiopia, provide the airline with a secure and cost-competitive compliance credit supply, and create a stable domestic demand anchor for Ethiopia’s carbon credit production.
Structuring this arrangement will require careful legal work. CORSIA credits used by Ethiopian Airlines will need to either carry corresponding adjustments (if the underlying activities are within Ethiopia’s NDC boundary) or be structured to avoid double-counting concerns.
- Practical Guide for Stakeholders:
For project developers in Ethiopia, the choice of international mechanism is not merely a technical matter. Rather, it determines revenue potential, buyer universe, compliance burden, and timeline. Here is a practical guide:
- Article 6.2 bilateral: Highest prices (government-to-government deals typically USD 15 to USD 50 or more per tCO₂e, depending on sector and co-benefits); requires ITMO authorization as a condition precedent; suited to large-scale activities with significant verified volumes.
- PACM (Article 6.4): UNFCCC-supervised; internationally credible; broader buyer access than bilateral deals; suited to projects wanting standardised methodology approval.
- VCM (Gold Standard): Fastest to market; largest buyer universe; no mandatory corresponding adjustment; suitable for projects prioritizing speed and flexibility.
- CORSIA: Specific, growing demand from aviation sector; mandatory phase begins 2027; Ethiopian Airlines as anchor domestic buyer; requires registration under ICAO-approved programme.
Conclusion
The international carbon market architecture is complex, but it is now settled in a way it has never been before. Nine years of difficult negotiations have produced a complete, legally operable Article 6 rulebook. The PACM is operational, and Article 6.2 bilateral deals can be executed with legal certainty. CORSIA’s mandatory phase is approaching. For Ethiopia, the external environment has never been more favourable.
The question that remains is whether Ethiopia’s domestic legal framework is ready to engage with this architecture effectively, converting international legal certainty into domestic transactional capacity. That is the subject of Part 4, the final instalment of this article. Coming up is a detailed examination of Ethiopia’s legal framework, from Proclamation No. 1065/2018 to Directive No. 1122/2025, with direct implications for opportunities on the ground.
This article is general information and not legal advice. Contact us about your specific situation.



